|
Comparative Causes of Annual Deaths in the United
States
Note: All mortality data are for 1990, except
alcohol, which is for 1987. Source: HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report; National
Safety Council Accident Facts; Monthly Vital Statistics Report; SAMMEC;
Alcohol-Related Death Index.
From the CDC's Tobacco Information &
Prevention Sourcepage
Notice how the CDC statistics are being skewed and
presented in a misleading way. If you just look at the graph alone without
evaluating what it's saying, you would have to conclude that smoking is THE
leading cause of death among Americans. But, is that true?
Where are the numbers for
heart disease, cancer, and stroke in people who NEVER smoked? What about people
who simply died from old age? How convenient. What is appearing to be a
consistent approach by liberals is to simply ignore any statistics that do not
fit their preconceived result.
I'm sure the CDC would like
you to infer that heart disease, cancer, and stroke is really caused by
smoking, as the following graph depicts. But, is
that true?
Deaths Attributable to Cigarette Smoking---United
States, 1990
Source:
CDC SAMMEC, MMWR 1993; 42:645-9.
I'm sure the CDC would be ecstatic if I were just to
blindly accept their version - but I don't! They expect me to find a terrible
crisis when of the more than 1,623,095 deaths attributable to heart disease,
cancer, and stroke - 25% are smoking related? What causes the other 75%?
Sure, they might be able to say
that 25% of those who died from these diseases were smokers, but what does that
prove? What percentage of those who died also regularly ate junk food, ate red
meat cooked over charcoal, drank coffee, tea, or soft drinks, ever flew in an
airplane, or took asprin? Are we to blame these things on their death? Or, hey
100% of them drank water. Might the water be contaminated?
One of the cardinal rules of
environmental toxicology is to identify the specific chemical(s) of concern,
because biological responses are highly specific. The simple exposure to a
given chemical, even if it is an established carcinogen, is by itself usually
not associated with development of cancer. Everyone is exposed to potentially
toxic or carcinogenic chemicals every day. Risk is not established by exposure
alone; it is established thru a dose-response relationship.
Folks, you can make statistics say
whatever you want them to say, and the CDC along with others wanting your money
are simply using that fact to manipulate and frighten you with misleading and
incomplete graphics.
|
|